Your great-grandmother's pie crust was legendary. Flaky, shatter-y, the kind people requested for every holiday. She used lard. Then Crisco showed up and told everyone that was the old, unhealthy way. A hundred years later, those of us who actually read labels are circling back to what she knew.

What You Are Actually Reaching For

Vegetable shortening is a fully hydrogenated or partially hydrogenated plant oil, usually soybean or palm oil, that has been chemically altered to stay solid at room temperature. It was invented in 1911 as a cheap industrial substitute for animal fats, and it has been marketed as a health food ever since.

The original formulation was loaded with trans fats. The FDA banned partially hydrogenated oils from the food supply in 2020, so most shortenings are now reformulated, but the base is still a heavily processed industrial seed oil. If your label says "interesterified fat" or "fully hydrogenated soybean oil," that is the replacement they landed on. It is not traditional. It is not food your body recognizes as ancestral fuel.

What Lard and Tallow Actually Are

Lard is rendered pork fat. Tallow is rendered beef fat. That is it. One ingredient, one source animal. Both have been used in kitchens for thousands of years.

Fat composition matters in baking, and here is where animal fats genuinely earn their place: lard is about 39% saturated fat, 45% monounsaturated fat, and 11% polyunsaturated fat according to USDA data, making it more stable under heat than most plant oils. Tallow skews slightly more saturated, running around 50% saturated and 42% monounsaturated. Neither oxidizes the way unstable polyunsaturated seed oils do at baking temperatures, which is one reason researchers have pointed to high-heat stability as a practical advantage for animal fats in cooking.

Pastured lard also carries meaningful amounts of vitamin D, a nutrient a significant portion of the American population is low in. That is a small thing, but it is not nothing.

What Honestly Changes When You Swap

Flakiness goes up. This is the thing bakers have known for generations and food science now backs: the large fat crystals in lard create distinct layers in dough, which is what makes a biscuit or pie crust genuinely flaky rather than crumbly. King Arthur Baking has tested this extensively and their bakers consistently describe lard crusts as producing more pronounced layers than shortening.

Flavor shifts slightly. Leaf lard (rendered from the fat around the kidneys) is mild and nearly neutral. Standard lard from the back fat has a faint pork note, barely detectable once baked into a sweet pie, more present in a savory hand pie or biscuit, where it actually works in your favor. Tallow has a beefier edge, so it is a better fit for savory applications, like beef-fat biscuits or a deep-dish crust that can handle the flavor.

Cost can run higher upfront. A good jar of leaf lard from a heritage farm costs more than a tub of Crisco. It also goes further and behaves better, so you tend to use less. Tallow is often cheaper than lard and extremely easy to render at home from beef suet if you have access to a butcher.

Sourcing takes a little more intention. Pasture-raised matters here, same as it does with any animal product, because the fat quality and nutrient profile reflect what the animal ate. Local butchers, farmers markets, and online farms are the realistic options for most people.

When the Swap Is Not Worth It

If you need a vegan or dairy-free bake, animal fats are obviously off the table. Coconut oil is the better real-food option there, with the caveat that it has a detectable flavor and behaves differently in doughs.

If you are making a very delicate, neutral-flavored dessert where any hint of savory would read as a mistake, standard back-fat lard may not be your friend. Leaf lard or refined tallow are better choices in that case.

And if you are brand new to real-food swaps, shortening in a cake recipe (not a pastry) is actually one of the lower-priority battles. Swapping the seed oils in your everyday cooking will move the needle more than agonizing over what goes into a birthday cake once a year.

How to Make the Switch Stick

Use a 1:1 replacement by weight or volume. Lard and tallow substitute directly for shortening in almost every recipe without adjustments.

Store lard in the refrigerator for up to a month or in the freezer for up to a year. Tallow is remarkably shelf-stable and can sit in a sealed jar at room temperature for several weeks.

Start with a pie crust or a biscuit. Those are the two places where the upgrade is most obvious and most rewarding. Once you taste what flaky actually means, you will not miss the Crisco.

This article is for general informational purposes only and is not medical advice. Always consult a qualified healthcare professional before making changes to your diet or health routine.

Key Takeaways

  • Vegetable shortening is a heavily processed industrial fat, originally made with trans fats and now reformulated with interesterified oils.
  • Lard and tallow are single-ingredient animal fats with centuries of kitchen use and high heat stability.
  • The swap is 1:1 by volume and works best in pie crusts, biscuits, and savory pastry.
  • Leaf lard is the most neutral option; tallow is best for savory bakes; standard lard has a mild pork note that works well in biscuits.
  • Pastured sourcing matters for fat quality, so look to local butchers, farmers markets, or reputable online farms.
  • If you are vegan or making a very neutral dessert, the swap may not be the right fit.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I substitute lard for shortening 1:1 in baking?

Yes. Lard substitutes directly for vegetable shortening in a 1:1 ratio by volume or weight in almost all baking recipes. No adjustments needed in most cases. It performs especially well in pie crusts, biscuits, and savory pastry.

Does lard make baked goods taste like pork?

Leaf lard, which is rendered from the fat around the kidneys, is very mild and nearly neutral in flavor. Standard back-fat lard has a faint pork note that is barely detectable in most sweet bakes but pleasant in biscuits and savory pastry. Tallow has a more pronounced beefy flavor and is best reserved for savory applications.

Is lard or tallow healthier than vegetable shortening?

Lard and tallow are unprocessed, single-ingredient animal fats with a long history of traditional use. Research on dietary fat is an evolving area, so this article won't make a blanket health claim. What is clear is that both are far less processed than modern vegetable shortening, which is derived from industrially refined seed oils. Talk to your healthcare provider about what fats are appropriate for your individual needs.

Where can I buy lard or tallow for baking?

Local butcher shops and farmers markets are the best starting point, especially if you want pastured quality. Many online farms ship shelf-stable lard and tallow. Some grocery stores carry lard in the baking or international foods aisle, though quality varies. For tallow, ask a butcher for beef suet and render it yourself at home.

Sources


This article is for general informational purposes only and is not medical advice. Always consult a qualified healthcare professional before making changes to your diet or health routine.